"Ireland without abortion ... safest country in the world"?

General discussions
Post Reply
aiseiri47
Atheist Ireland Member
Atheist Ireland Member
Posts: 177
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2010 1:25 pm

"Ireland without abortion ... safest country in the world"?

Post by aiseiri47 » Thu May 12, 2011 7:25 pm

Just came across a link (via something a friend "Liked" on Facebook) associated with an "initiative" by Pro-Life Campaign which claims that "Ireland without abortion is the safest country in the world for pregnant women." (http://www.prolifecampaign.ie/pages.php?id=167)

I was intrigued by this claim, first because it is apparently supported by the WHO, which I find surprising. I'm also not entirely sure what is meant by it - the wording seems awkward to me. Perhaps Ireland without abortion is safe for pregnant women, but is a country without abortion not incredibly unsafe for women?

I tried doing a search myself, but finding any article that was not biased in favour of PLC was nearly impossible; I found one article on the IFPA website that mentions the campaign while discussing the issue that women are being "grossly misled" about the health risks of abortion, but still no specific mention or reference to what the WHO have to do with this claim. (http://www.ifpa.ie/eng/Media-Info/News- ... tion-risks)

It's not a very recent story, it's circa January this year, but I was wondering if anyone else was aware of the campaign and what the WHO's supposed link is with it?

(*Sorry if this forum is the wrong place for this topic; I didn't think it held particular relevance to any of the other discussion sub-forums, and but that it was closely enough associated with "philosophy" to post it here rather than in the Off-Topic forum).
mkaobrih
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 1601
Joined: Wed Sep 05, 2007 10:48 pm

Re: "Ireland without abortion ... safest country in the world"?

Post by mkaobrih » Thu May 12, 2011 8:00 pm

I think (vaguely remember reading about this) that the WHO report was about the care of pregnant women in Ireland and safe baby deliveries – nothing about abortion. So although Ireland is without abortion and Ireland tops the table in ante-natal care post hoc, ergo propter hoc.
The church complains of persecution when it's not allowed to persecute.
oldrnwisr
Atheist Ireland Member
Atheist Ireland Member
Posts: 80
Joined: Tue Mar 04, 2008 4:09 pm
Location: Limerick, Ireland
Contact:

Re: "Ireland without abortion ... safest country in the world"?

Post by oldrnwisr » Thu May 12, 2011 8:17 pm

aiseiri47 wrote:Just came across a link (via something a friend "Liked" on Facebook) associated with an "initiative" by Pro-Life Campaign which claims that "Ireland without abortion is the safest country in the world for pregnant women." (http://www.prolifecampaign.ie/pages.php?id=167)

I was intrigued by this claim, first because it is apparently supported by the WHO, which I find surprising. I'm also not entirely sure what is meant by it - the wording seems awkward to me. Perhaps Ireland without abortion is safe for pregnant women, but is a country without abortion not incredibly unsafe for women?

I tried doing a search myself, but finding any article that was not biased in favour of PLC was nearly impossible; I found one article on the IFPA website that mentions the campaign while discussing the issue that women are being "grossly misled" about the health risks of abortion, but still no specific mention or reference to what the WHO have to do with this claim. (http://www.ifpa.ie/eng/Media-Info/News- ... tion-risks)

It's not a very recent story, it's circa January this year, but I was wondering if anyone else was aware of the campaign and what the WHO's supposed link is with it?

(*Sorry if this forum is the wrong place for this topic; I didn't think it held particular relevance to any of the other discussion sub-forums, and but that it was closely enough associated with "philosophy" to post it here rather than in the Off-Topic forum).
This is another one of those typically dishonest campaigns which proves again that correlation is not causation. There are a number of problems with the campaign's claim that Ireland is the safest country in the world for pregnant women.

The first thing is to identiy the measurement used to determine safety. The WHO monitor a metric known as the Maternal Mortality Ration (MMR) which is defined as the number of maternal deaths per 100,000 live births. The WHO use this as a measure of the quality of the health system of a country. The countries at the top of the list, Ireland, Europe, USA etc. tend to have good quality healthcare systems and an MMR of less than 20. On the other end of the scale is developing countries like Afghanistan, Sierra Leone and Rwanda.

The first problem with the campaign's claim is that it is flat out wrong, or at least out-of-date. The idea that Ireland has the lowest MMR is taken from the 2000 WHO figures where Ireland has an MMR of 0. The thing is though that the most recent figures show Ireland to have an MMR of 5 in line with other European countries while Iceland, a country where abortion is completely legal scores 0.

The next problem comes from a comparison of the MMR scores of various countries and their abortion laws. Ireland has a low MMR and abortion is illegal but so too do the rest of Europe where there are varying laws on abortion. At the other end of the scale, Afghanistan which has a reasonably similar stance on abortion to Ireland also has one of the highest MMR.

The biggest problem with the use of the WHO statistics of course is that the WHO themselves have already analysed the causal factors of the MMR. The factors which cause high MMR rates include severe bleeding, eclampsia, infection and other causes both direct and indirect. They do highlight unsafe abortion as a causal factor but only in 13% of cases.

The campaign is the same kind of bullshit that I've come to expect from a lot of pro-life groups. I have even submitted a complaint to ASAI about their billboards but since they are intended to sway opinion lying to people is ok. Their website contains no links to primary sources and no original research to back up their claims. It's just the usual appeals to emotion and appeals to consequences of a belief fallacies that you get from these people.
"Science doesn't know everything. Religion doesn't know anything." AronRa - WAC 2011
aiseiri47
Atheist Ireland Member
Atheist Ireland Member
Posts: 177
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2010 1:25 pm

Re: "Ireland without abortion ... safest country in the world"?

Post by aiseiri47 » Thu May 12, 2011 8:32 pm

Thanks for the explainations; mkaobrih, I thought that might be the case :|

oldrnwisr, regarding the information you provided - while I fully expected it to be a twisting of truths, it seems completely out of line to be using completely out-of-date and currently irrelevant (and thus false) statistics in a current advertising campaign. This campaign was launched this year; surely there are regulations that prevent any organization or campaign from using blatant mistruths in any kind of public advertising? If it was a company trying to sell something they'd be guilty of false advertisement, how can PLC not be subject to similar policies? Is there somebody to monitor this?

(Sorry if I sound ignorant or naive about these things, but I've only lived in Ireland as an adult for three years so I generally am ignorant and naive about these things.)
oldrnwisr
Atheist Ireland Member
Atheist Ireland Member
Posts: 80
Joined: Tue Mar 04, 2008 4:09 pm
Location: Limerick, Ireland
Contact:

Re: "Ireland without abortion ... safest country in the world"?

Post by oldrnwisr » Thu May 12, 2011 8:45 pm

aiseiri47 wrote: oldrnwisr, regarding the information you provided - while I fully expected it to be a twisting of truths, it seems completely out of line to be using completely out-of-date and currently irrelevant (and thus false) statistics in a current advertising campaign. This campaign was launched this year; surely there are regulations that prevent any organization or campaign from using blatant mistruths in any kind of public advertising? If it was a company trying to sell something they'd be guilty of false advertisement, how can PLC not be subject to similar policies? Is there somebody to monitor this?
I would have thought the same as you before I decided to find out for sure. There was a thread on the boards before about a stem-cell billboard campaign fronted by Youth Defence. The billboard messages were misleading to say the least and so I complained to the Advertising Standards Authority. The reply I received from the ASAI stated that because the billboard was designed to influence public opinion and not market a product that it was not within their remit to make any kind of judgment about the billboard.

Thread here:
viewtopic.php?f=1&t=2097
"Science doesn't know everything. Religion doesn't know anything." AronRa - WAC 2011
Marks
Atheist Ireland Member
Atheist Ireland Member
Posts: 362
Joined: Mon Sep 07, 2009 12:09 pm

Re: "Ireland without abortion ... safest country in the world"?

Post by Marks » Thu May 12, 2011 8:46 pm

For the best understanding of the Constitution in Ireland on abortion without prejudice is the A, B, C case v Ireland at the European Court of Human Rights.

http://www.irishtimes.com/focus/2010/echr/index.pdf

In relation to the figures that you are speaking about an understanding of what exactly is happening on the ground might help. After you read this case maybe the question to ask yourself is:-
Are there any valid figures in relation to pregnant woman with life threatening conditions in Ireland?
If not, is Ireland without abortion is the safest country in the world for pregnant women?
kerachery
Posts: 1
Joined: Tue Oct 11, 2011 7:29 am

Re: "Ireland without abortion ... safest country in the world"?

Post by kerachery » Thu Oct 13, 2011 7:07 am

What is the definition of abortion strictly in the Philippine setting? Oh yes, in the Philippines only. As i browse the internet, i see several and different definitions of abortion depending on the country and depending the time i.e. before and at present it is being referred to.
__________________________
Last edited by kerachery on Sat Oct 15, 2011 7:10 am, edited 1 time in total.
I post spam and I'm banned.
Dr Raskolnikov
Posts: 197
Joined: Thu Nov 26, 2009 11:16 pm
Location: "In the beginning there was the word, and the word was "word up biatch""

Re: "Ireland without abortion ... safest country in the world"?

Post by Dr Raskolnikov » Thu Oct 13, 2011 7:39 am

kerachery wrote:What is the definition of abortion strictly in the Philippine setting? Oh yes, in the Philippines only. As i browse the internet, i see several and different definitions of abortion depending on the country and depending the time i.e. before and at present it is being referred to.
For this question to be sensibly responded to, it would be useful if you could provide your own definition of abortion...
Science is like a blabbermouth who ruins the movie by telling you how it ends. Well, I say there are some things we don't want to know. Important things. - Ned Flanders
Post Reply